Recent changes to the US National Security Council (NSC) should be ringing loud alarm bells in Canberra.
Recent changes to the US National Security Council (NSC) should be ringing loud alarm bells in Canberra. By demoting the highest ranking military officer and the highest ranking intelligence officer, and appointing political adviser Stephen Bannon as a permanent member of the NSC, Donald Trump has seriously escalated the risk of the US launching into ill-advised conflicts. Stephen Bannon comes from a role as chairman of the racist, Islamophobic website Breitbart.com, and is reported as having been in charge of writing the recent executive order that has banned US entry for refugees and citizens from seven Muslim majority nations.
It is no secret that Australian foreign policy and defence forces are very closely enmeshed with the US. Since Donald Trump has taken office he has loudly proclaimed an “America First” foreign policy, and his Secretary of State Rex Tillerson talks of denying China access to artificial islands in the South China Sea. Any such blockade is likely to be seen by the Chinese as an act of war.
Malcolm Turnbull’s meek response to the immigration executive order does not inspire confidence that he will stand up to the US. Historically Australia’s foreign policy has also leaned towards “America first”, with little differentiation between our ally’s interests and our own. In rushing to join the coalition going into Iraq, the thought that Australia may be better off not invading another country on the basis of dubious intelligence was overlooked. Indeed, in the Vietnam War, the CIA knew the war was unwinnable, even before Australia sent troops. Malcolm Fraser, defence minister at the time, was livid when he found this out many years later. 521 Australian troops died in Vietnam and about 3,000 were wounded.
Since WWII, Australia has joined in more US wars than any other ally. With Canberra’s current “business-as-usual” agenda, Australia is at high risk of joining further US wars that again create humanitarian disasters and undermine our security. Simultaneously there is talk of expanding US bases in the region. What is Australia going to say when the US asks to increase their bases on our soil? Are we willing to make Australia a target? For example CIA documents from the 1980s released this month revealed authorities expected the Pine Gap spy base near Alice Springs to be attacked in the event of a US-Soviet nuclear fight.
Australia has US marines based in Darwin, multiple surveillance bases and around forty senior Australian Army officers working in US Pacific Command. This includes an Australian Army Major General serving as the Deputy Commanding General – Operations, US Army Pacific. This intense enmeshment reinforces Australia’s past behaviour – when the US goes to war, we have little option but to follow. With the US building up its military bases around China, American threats of blockades in the South China Sea are reckless and provocative. A war between China and the US is not in Australia’s interests or anyone’s interests.
Another example of US influence has been Australia’s behaviour at recent UN talks regarding the nuclear weapons ban treaty. Australia has acted as US proxy in trying to thwart these negotiations. So much so that the Australian delegation was dubbed the chief of the “Weasel states”. Despite Australia’s efforts, negotiations for a nuclear weapons ban treaty will be going ahead later this year. Australia has not yet committed to participating, which calls into question our government’s commitment to the UN.
Australia urgently needs to re-evaluate our American bases, and promote steps that defuse rather than intensify regional tensions. Having senior Australian defence personnel integrated into the US defence force hinders Australia acting independently. Do we want Australia to be capable of making strategic decisions in the national interest? New Zealand clearly acts in its own interest and remains an ally.
With Donald Trump now the new US commander in chief, is it wise that we allow ourselves to be so automatically tied to American foreign policy? War in our region would be a humanitarian catastrophe for all countries involved.
Margaret Beavis is a Melbourne GP and President of the Medical Association for Prevention of War